Memory Lane: These Are The Season 2 All Stars Newbies’ Original Cast Photos

The Season 2 All Stars are embarking on “one more fight to set things right.” But before the Challenge legends get a “do over” beginning November 11– some haven’t competed in years and years — we’re remembering their MTV roots. That’s right: It’s the All Stars newbies’ original cast photos from deep in our archives — and here’s the returning players from Season 1, in case you missed it several months back.

From Real World to Road Rules (and a bit of Fresh Meat), these images were the first taste of the young adults’ debut on the network. From posing in new real cities while living with seven strangers to hitting the road and soaking up the temporary locations, they all have the same fresh-faced energy. And they are sure to make you feel some major nostalgia.

• Ayanna Mackins
  

  Road Rules: Semester at Sea

• Brad Fiorenza
  Zach Cordner

  The Real World: San Diego

• Casey Cooper
  

  Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat

• Cohutta Grindstaff
  

  The Real World: Sydney

• Derek Chavez
  

  The Real World: Cancun

• Jodi Weatherton
  Zach Cordner

  Road Rules: X-Treme

• Janelle Casanave
  

  The Real World: Key West

• Jasmine Reynaud
  

  The Real World: Cancun

• Leah Gillingwater
  Rudy Archuleta

  The Real World: Paris

• Melinda Collins
  Michael Muller

  The Real World: Austin

• MJ Garrett
  

  The Real World: Philadelphia

• Ryan Kehoe
  

  Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat

• Tina Barta
  Andrew Shapter

  Road Rules: South Pacific

• Tyler Duckworth
  

  The Real World: Key West

A note: Sophia Pasquis and Steve Meinke from Road Rules: The Quest are not featured in this listicle — but they will be back beginning on November 11 and you can see their new cast photos here.